
Over$800M+Recovered

Erb's Palsy: Causes, Treatment and Birth Injury Claims
- Free Consultation
- No Fee Unless We Win
- Over $800M+ Recovered
- Serving Clients Nationwide

Reviewed by Attorney Charles Gilman
Published: 2 Oct 2026 • 20 min read
Erb's palsy is weakness or paralysis in a baby's shoulder and upper arm. It is caused by damage to the upper nerves of the brachial plexus, usually the C5 and C6 nerve roots, during birth. Erb's palsy is an upper brachial plexus injury, and many cases are linked to excessive stretching of a baby's neck during a difficult delivery. Some babies recover with therapy. Others need surgery or live with lasting weakness.
This guide explains the condition, the "waiter's tip" posture, treatment and recovery, and when the care itself deserves a closer look. Our birth injury practice is led by Briggs Bedigian, a trial lawyer who has tried more than 70 cases to verdict. Those verdicts include the $182 million birth injury verdict against the University of Pennsylvania (Hagans v. Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania), the largest medical malpractice verdict in Pennsylvania history. Briggs Bedigian prepares every case for trial. He explains that a brachial plexus claim usually turns on a few minutes of delivery-room decisions, and on what the records show about them.
If your child was diagnosed with Erb's palsy and you have questions about how the delivery was handled, Gilman & Bedigian can review what happened. We have recovered over $800 million for clients. We take all personal injury cases on a contingency fee basis, so there is no fee unless we win. We answer our phone 24/7. Call (800) 529-6162 to talk with our team.
Key Takeaways
- Erb's palsy affects the upper brachial plexus (C5 and C6, sometimes C7). It mainly weakens the shoulder and elbow, and the hand often still works.
- The classic sign is the "waiter's tip" position: the arm hangs at the side, turned inward, with the elbow straight and the wrist bent.
- Stretch injuries often improve with therapy. Torn nerves and nerves pulled from the spinal cord do not heal on their own and may need surgery.
- An Erb's palsy diagnosis does not prove malpractice. A claim requires showing that care fell below the accepted standard and caused the injury.
- Filing deadlines differ by state. The child's claim and the parents' claim for medical bills can run on separate clocks.
What Is Erb's Palsy, and How Does It Affect a Newborn?
Erb's palsy is a form of brachial plexus birth injury that affects the upper nerve roots in a baby's neck. It weakens the muscles that lift and rotate the shoulder and bend the elbow, while finger and hand function are often spared. The condition is also called Erb-Duchenne palsy or upper brachial plexus palsy.
The brachial plexus is a network of five nerves (C5 through T1) that leaves the spinal cord in the neck and runs through the shoulder into the arm. Together these nerves control movement and feeling from the shoulder to the fingertips.
In Erb's palsy, the injury involves the upper part of that network:
- C5 helps raise the arm out to the side and rotate the shoulder outward.
- C6 helps bend the elbow and turn the palm upward.
- C7, when involved, helps straighten the elbow and lift the wrist. Doctors sometimes call this "extended Erb's palsy."
Erb's palsy usually affects one arm. It sits within a wider group of conditions covered in our overview of brachial plexus birth injuries, which also explains injuries to the lower nerves and the entire plexus.
The good news is real: many babies improve. The harder truth is that the outcome depends heavily on how badly the nerves were damaged, and that is not always clear in the first weeks.
What Are the Types of Erb's Palsy Nerve Injuries?
Doctors classify Erb's palsy by the type of damage to the nerve, not just by which nerves are involved. The type of nerve injury, from a mild stretch to a nerve torn from the spinal cord, is the strongest single factor in whether a child recovers without surgery.
| Injury Type | What Happens to the Nerve | General Outlook | Common Treatment Path |
|---|---|---|---|
| Neurapraxia (stretch) | The nerve is stretched and stunned but not torn | Often improves, sometimes fully | Physical therapy and home range-of-motion work |
| Neuroma | The nerve is stretched hard enough to scar, and scar tissue blocks some signals | Partial recovery is common; some weakness may remain | Therapy; surgery may be considered if recovery stalls |
| Rupture | The nerve is torn, but not where it attaches to the spinal cord | Does not heal on its own | Nerve surgery, such as a graft, is often evaluated |
| Avulsion | The nerve root is pulled away from the spinal cord | Does not heal on its own; the most severe form | Nerve transfer surgery and long-term therapy |
Neurapraxia is the mildest nerve injury. The nerve's outer covering is irritated or compressed, but the nerve fibers stay intact, so signals can return as the nerve heals.
An avulsion means the nerve root has been torn out of the spinal cord itself. Because the nerve cannot be reattached at that point, surgeons may "borrow" a working nerve from nearby and connect it to the injured pathway.
Erb's palsy is different from Klumpke's palsy, which involves the lower nerves (C8 and T1) and mainly affects the hand and wrist. You can read more about that condition in our guide to Klumpke's palsy. When all five nerves are injured, doctors call it a total or global brachial plexus palsy.
What Causes Erb's Palsy During Delivery?
Erb's palsy happens when the baby's head and neck are pulled away from the shoulder with enough force to stretch or tear the upper nerves. The most common setting is shoulder dystocia, where the baby's shoulder catches behind the mother's pelvic bone after the head is delivered.
Shoulder dystocia is an obstetric emergency in which the baby's head is out, but a shoulder is stuck. The care team must free the shoulder quickly with specific maneuvers, because the baby cannot breathe normally until delivery is complete. Our page on shoulder dystocia explains those maneuvers in more depth.
Risk Factors Providers Are Expected to Watch
Several conditions raise the chance of a difficult shoulder delivery. A careful provider considers them before and during labor:
- A large baby (fetal macrosomia), especially when estimated weight is high
- Maternal diabetes, including gestational diabetes
- A prior delivery complicated by shoulder dystocia
- A long or stalled second stage of labor
- Vacuum or forceps delivery
- Breech delivery, where the baby comes out feet or bottom first
None of these factors guarantees an injury. They matter because they shape the delivery plan. They can affect whether a cesarean section is discussed, who is present at delivery, and how prepared the team is if the shoulder sticks.
Causes That May Point to a Care Failure
Certain events raise legitimate questions about the care:
- Pulling hard on the baby's head, or pulling it sideways, to free a stuck shoulder
- Failing to use recognized shoulder dystocia maneuvers in a timely, orderly way
- Not recognizing or discussing known risk factors before labor
- Misusing a vacuum or forceps
- Mismanaging a breech delivery
Causes That May Not Involve Negligence
Not every Erb's palsy case comes from a mistake. Defense experts often argue that the mother's own pushing, the baby's position in the womb, or other factors contributed to the injury. That is why causation must be tested by qualified medical experts, not assumed.
What Does the Waiter's Tip Position Look Like? Signs by Age
The waiter's tip position is the classic posture of Erb's palsy. The affected arm hangs at the baby's side, rotated inward, with the elbow straight, the forearm turned palm-down or back, and the wrist and fingers bent. It resembles a waiter discreetly holding out a hand for a tip.
Signs at Birth and in the First Days
- One arm lies limp or moves much less than the other
- The arm is held in the waiter's tip position
- The startle (Moro) reflex is uneven, with only one arm reaching out
- The grasp reflex in the hand is often still present
- The baby may seem uncomfortable when the arm is moved
Signs Over the First Months
- Difficulty lifting the arm or bringing the hand to the mouth
- Weak elbow bending
- Trouble turning the palm upward
- Tightness or stiffness in the shoulder
Signs Later in Childhood
- A shorter or smaller affected arm
- Limited shoulder rotation, which can make reaching overhead or behind the back difficult
- Muscle imbalance and joint changes at the shoulder
Any newborn who isn't moving one arm normally should be examined promptly. Our page on the signs of a birth injury covers other warning signs parents may notice.
How Do Doctors Diagnose an Upper Brachial Plexus Injury?
Most Erb's palsy diagnoses begin with a physical exam soon after birth. A pediatrician or neonatologist usually identifies the problem by watching how the baby moves each arm and testing reflexes, and then refers the family to a specialist.
The diagnostic process often includes:
- Physical exam: checking arm position, movement, reflexes and muscle tone.
- X-rays: ruling out a broken collarbone (clavicle) or upper arm bone, which can also make a baby hold the arm still.
- Specialist referral: many families are sent to a brachial plexus clinic, where pediatric neurology, orthopedics, plastic surgery and therapy teams work together.
- Serial exams: tracking recovery over weeks and months, often focusing on whether the biceps muscle starts working.
- Nerve studies and imaging: electromyography (EMG), nerve conduction studies, and MRI or CT imaging may help show the type and location of nerve damage when surgery is being considered.
Doctors also watch for signs that point to more severe injury. One example is a drooping eyelid and small pupil on the same side, called Horner syndrome. It can suggest that lower nerve roots are involved or that a nerve has been pulled from the spinal cord.
How Is Erb's Palsy Treated? Therapy, Exercises and Surgery
Treatment depends on the type of nerve injury and how the child recovers over time. Therapy is the foundation of care for nearly every child with Erb's palsy. Surgery is generally considered when key muscles show too little recovery within the first several months. Your child's medical team decides the right plan; the summary below explains what families commonly encounter.
Physical and Occupational Therapy
Therapy usually starts early, once the care team decides gentle movement is safe. Therapists work to keep the joints flexible, prevent stiffness, and help the child learn to use the arm. Occupational therapists focus on daily tasks as the child grows, such as feeding, dressing and writing.
Erb's Palsy Exercises Families Are Often Taught
Parents typically learn a home routine from their child's therapist. Common elements include:
- Gentle range-of-motion work for the shoulder, elbow, forearm and wrist, done several times a day as instructed
- Shoulder rotation stretches to prevent the arm from stiffening in the inward-turned position
- Tummy time to build shoulder and neck strength
- Play-based reaching with toys placed to encourage use of the affected arm
- Sensory activities such as touch and texture play to build awareness of the arm
These exercises should only be done as your therapist teaches them. A baby's joints are delicate, and forcing a stiff shoulder can cause harm.
Splints, Taping and Injections
Some children use splints or therapeutic taping to support joint position. Doctors sometimes use botulinum toxin (Botox) injections to temporarily relax overactive muscles, which can help weaker muscles strengthen and improve therapy results.
Nerve Surgery
When a nerve is torn or avulsed, or when recovery stalls, surgeons may recommend:
- Nerve grafts: replacing a damaged section with a piece of nerve taken from elsewhere in the body
- Nerve transfers: rerouting a healthy nearby nerve to power a paralyzed muscle
- Neurolysis: removing scar tissue around a nerve
Later Procedures
Some children need procedures years later. These may include tendon transfers, muscle releases, or bone surgery to improve shoulder rotation and address joint changes. For a broader view of therapies across birth injuries, see the treatment and management resources on our birth injury hub.
What Does Erb's Palsy Recovery Look Like Over Time?
Erb's palsy recovery varies widely from child to child. Many babies with stretch-type injuries regain much or all of their arm function, often showing improvement in the first few months, while ruptures and avulsions usually leave some lasting weakness even after surgery.
Factors that tend to shape the outlook include:
- Type of nerve injury: stretch injuries have the best outlook
- Number of nerves involved: C5–C6 injuries generally fare better than injuries that extend to C7 or the full plexus
- Early signs of recovery: returning biceps function is one marker doctors watch closely
- Consistency of therapy: keeping joints flexible helps prevent stiffness that can limit function later
- Timing of surgery, when surgery is needed
Children with lasting effects may have a shorter arm, shoulder stiffness, or weakness that affects sports and daily activities. Many adapt well and lead active lives. No one should predict a specific child's prognosis from a general article, and your child's specialists are the right source for that conversation.
Here's why that matters for families: recovery often isn't clear for months. A child who seems to be improving may plateau. That uncertainty affects both medical planning and any legal evaluation.
What Lifetime Costs Can Erb's Palsy Create?
The cost of Erb's palsy depends on how fully the child recovers. A mild injury may require months of therapy, while a permanent injury can create medical, therapy and support needs that last into adulthood.
Families may face costs for:
- Specialist visits, imaging and nerve studies
- Physical and occupational therapy, sometimes for years
- Nerve surgery and later orthopedic procedures
- Splints, adaptive equipment and assistive devices
- Botox injections or other medical treatments
- Educational support or classroom accommodations
- Lost income when a parent reduces work hours for appointments
- The child's reduced earning capacity, if weakness limits future work
For a permanent injury, a life care plan is often prepared. This is a detailed projection, usually written by a medical or rehabilitation professional, of the care, therapy, equipment and support a person will need over their lifetime and what it will cost. You can learn more about how birth injury compensation is calculated.
When Is Erb's Palsy Caused by Medical Malpractice?
Erb's palsy may be malpractice when a provider failed to meet the accepted standard of care and that failure caused the nerve injury. A bad outcome alone does not prove negligence; the question is whether the delivery care fell short and whether that shortfall, rather than another factor, injured the baby.
The standard of care is what a reasonably careful provider in the same field would have done in similar circumstances. Obstetricians, midwives and labor and delivery nurses are each measured against the standard for their own profession.
Questions That Commonly Raise Concern
- Were risk factors such as a large baby or maternal diabetes recognized and discussed before labor?
- Was a cesarean delivery considered when the risk profile called for that conversation?
- When the shoulder became stuck, did the team use recognized maneuvers?
- Was excessive or sideways force applied to the baby's head?
- Was a vacuum or forceps used appropriately?
Records That Matter Most
Answering those questions requires the complete chart, not a summary. Key records often include prenatal visit notes, ultrasound weight estimates, labor and delivery nursing notes, the delivery note describing any shoulder dystocia, the timing of each maneuver, newborn exam findings, and the electronic audit trail showing when entries were made. Patients have a federal right to copies of their records under 45 C.F.R. § 164.524.
Deadlines and Rules Differ by State
Every state sets its own filing deadlines, pre-suit requirements and damages rules for malpractice claims. A birth injury can create two separate claims with different deadlines: the child's own claim and the parents' claim for medical expenses during childhood.
As one example, in Maryland, where our firm is headquartered in Timonium, a child's own malpractice claim is measured from the child's 18th birthday, because Piselli v. 75th Street Medical, 371 Md. 188 (2002), held the statute's earlier start for children unconstitutional. But the parents' claim for the child's medical expenses before age 18 is not paused for the child's age (Garay v. Overholtzer). Maryland also requires most malpractice claims to begin at the Health Care Alternative Dispute Resolution Office, with a Certificate of Qualified Expert due within 90 days. Other states use different rules, and some deadlines are much shorter. Our article on how much time you have to file a malpractice claim after a birth injury explains more.
If the delivery took place at a federally funded community health center or a federal facility, a different process may apply. Claims involving providers deemed federal employees go through the Federal Tort Claims Act. That law requires a written administrative claim to the agency within two years (28 U.S.C. § 2401(b)) before a lawsuit can be filed (28 U.S.C. § 2675(a)).
If something about your child's delivery doesn't sit right, you don't have to sort out these rules alone. You can reach us at (800) 529-6162 to ask how the deadlines may apply to your family.
How Gilman & Bedigian Investigates Erb's Palsy Claims
When we accept a birth injury case, we gather the records, consult appropriate experts, identify the responsible parties, and document the full impact of the injury. Briggs Bedigian prepares every case as if it will go to trial, because that preparation gives families a realistic basis for judging any settlement offer.
Our process for a brachial plexus case generally includes:
- Sorting the claims and deadlines: identifying the child's claim, the parents' claim and the rules of the state where care took place.
- Rebuilding the delivery timeline: placing nursing notes, physician entries and audit trails side by side to see what the team knew and when.
- Testing causation: working with medical experts to evaluate whether the injury came from delivery care or from another factor the defense may raise. Some of our trial attorneys previously represented doctors, hospitals and a health system, and that background helps anticipate defense arguments.
- Measuring lifetime needs: working with life care planners and economists when an injury may be permanent.
- Weighing settlement against trial: negotiating from preparation and remaining ready to try the case when that is necessary.
Briggs Bedigian was inducted into The Inner Circle of Advocates in 2015 and was named the 2013 Trial Lawyer of the Year by the Maryland Trial Lawyers Association. Firm co-founder Charles Gilman has lectured fellow lawyers, at their request, on the use of expert witnesses at trial, a skill central to cases like these.
Our birth injury results include the $55 million verdict in Martinez v. Johns Hopkins Hospital, the second-largest medical malpractice verdict in Maryland history, and a $108,577,132 birth injury verdict against Jefferson Health and Einstein Pediatrics in Philadelphia County. Those results reflect our trial experience; they do not predict the outcome of any other case. Learn more on our birth injury page.
The information on this page is general and does not constitute legal advice. Every case is different, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Please consult an attorney about your family's specific situation.
If you believe a medical error played a part in your child's Erb's palsy, we're here to listen. You pay no attorney fee unless we recover for you, and we can explain how case expenses are handled. Call Gilman & Bedigian at (800) 529-6162 to start a confidential conversation about your child's delivery.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can Erb's palsy heal on its own?
Many babies with mild stretch injuries improve significantly, and some recover fully, usually with the help of physical therapy. Recovery is less likely without treatment when a nerve is torn or pulled from the spinal cord, because those injuries do not heal on their own. Doctors track a baby's progress over the first months to decide whether therapy alone is enough or whether nerve surgery should be considered.
How much does a birth injury attorney cost?
We take all personal injury cases on a contingency fee basis. That means you pay no attorney fee unless we win. Case expenses, such as expert review and medical record costs, are a separate item, and we explain how they are handled before you decide anything. Fee rules for malpractice cases also vary by state; some states require a court or panel to approve attorney fees.
How long do I have to file an Erb's palsy lawsuit?
It depends on the state where the delivery happened. Many states give children extra time, but the parents' claim for medical bills may run on a shorter clock. In Maryland, for example, a child's own claim is measured from the child's 18th birthday under Piselli v. 75th Street Medical, while the parents' expense claim is not paused for the child's age. Because rules vary, it is wise to ask a lawyer early.
What is my child's Erb's palsy case worth?
No one can value a case without reviewing the records and understanding how fully the child is expected to recover. Value depends on whether negligence can be proven, whether it caused the injury, and the child's lifetime needs. Medical costs, therapy, surgery, future earning capacity and pain and suffering may all be part of a claim. Some states, including Maryland, cap non-economic damages in malpractice cases.
Should I accept the first settlement offer from the hospital's insurer?
Not before you understand your child's long-term needs. In a brachial plexus case, the full extent of recovery may not be clear for months or longer, and an early offer may not account for future surgeries or therapy. Settlements involving children often require court approval, and funds may be structured or placed in a trust to protect the child.
What if I was partly at fault for my baby's injury?
In most Erb's palsy cases, the questions are about the medical care, not anything a parent did. Fault rules vary by state. In Maryland, which keeps contributory negligence, the defense can raise a patient's own fault in a malpractice case typically where the patient did not follow, or unreasonably delayed following, a treating provider's instructions. Parents often blame themselves, but that is rarely where the evidence points.
How long does a birth injury case take to resolve?
Timing depends on the state's pre-suit rules, how many providers are involved, the expert review, and whether the case settles or goes to trial. Some states require screening panels or expert certificates before a lawsuit moves forward. Cases involving permanent injuries may also take longer, because the child's future needs must be understood. See our article on how long a birth injury lawsuit takes.
Do I need a lawyer for an Erb's palsy claim?
Malpractice claims usually require medical expert testimony on the standard of care and causation, and many states require expert support early in the case. They also involve strict deadlines and procedural rules. A lawyer who handles birth injury cases can obtain the complete records, work with experts and explain whether a claim is worth pursuing before your family invests time in one.
What if the provider doesn't have insurance?
Hospitals and physicians generally carry professional liability coverage or are self-insured, though requirements differ by state. When a hospital employs the provider, the hospital may also be responsible. If the delivery happened at a federally funded health center, the claim may go through the Federal Tort Claims Act instead, which requires a written administrative claim within two years.
How do we pay for my child's treatment while a case is pending?
Most families use private health insurance or Medicaid, and many states offer early intervention programs for infants with developmental needs. Insurers and Medicaid may have a right to be repaid from any recovery, so those liens are addressed before a settlement is finalized. Keeping copies of bills and insurance statements helps document your child's costs.
If you'd like to talk through any of these questions as they apply to your family, call Gilman & Bedigian at (800) 529-6162.
Birth Injury Practice Areas
Birth Injury Practice Areas
Explore the full range of birth injury matters we handle.
Birth Injury overview →
